How come Indian managers are globally amongst the best Talent and India has many Global CEOs but not a single management concept or theory has emerged from India. What do you think is the problem.
Indian managers excel globally due to their adaptability, resilience, and ability to navigate complex, diverse environments. Many thrive in high-pressure roles, leveraging strong technical skills, cultural fluency, and a knack for frugal innovation (jugaad). This has propelled leaders like Satya Nadella, Sundar Pichai, and Indra Nooyi to global CEO roles. However, the absence of a distinct Indian management concept or theory is notable. Here’s why this might be the case:
Cultural Emphasis on Application Over Theorization: Indian professionals often prioritize practical problem-solving over formalizing frameworks. The cultural focus on execution and results, rooted in resource-constrained environments, may lead to effective practices that remain implicit rather than being codified into universal theories. In India, there’s a stronger focus on applying existing global practices rather than investing time and resources into creating new theoretical models.
Western Dominance in Management Academia: Management theories often emerge from Western institutions like Harvard or MIT, which have robust ecosystems for research, publication, and global dissemination. India’s academic institutions, while improving, historically lack similar infrastructure or global influence to formalize and promote indigenous concepts. Indian management research often stays within academic circles and doesn’t always connect directly with industry needs or gain global recognition.
Also read – Mandatory Registration of Internal committee under PoSH Law on the SHe-Box Portal in Delhi and Rajasthan
Colonial Legacy and Western Influence: India’s management education has been heavily influenced by Western models (e.g., IIMs adopting Harvard-style case studies). This may discourage the development of uniquely Indian frameworks, as Western theories are often seen as the gold standard. For a long time, Western models have dominated management education in India. Many institutions still rely heavily on those frameworks, leaving less room for indigenous thought.
Lack of Documentation of Indigenous Practices: Concepts like jugaad or relational leadership (emphasizing community and hierarchy) are prevalent in Indian management but rarely documented systematically. Without rigorous research or global advocacy, these practices don’t gain traction as formal theories.
Global Perception and Branding: Indian management practices may be undervalued or stereotyped as context-specific rather than universally applicable. Western theories are often packaged as globally relevant, while Indian approaches are seen as niche or informal. Some unique Indian practices like “Jugaad” innovation and values-based leadership do exist, but they aren’t always formalized or marketed globally as structured theories.
Focus on Individual Success Over Systemic Contribution: Indian managers often focus on personal career advancement in global corporations rather than contributing to theoretical frameworks. The incentive structure rewards practical success over academic or theoretical innovation.
Potential Solutions
- Invest in Management Research: Indian institutions like IIMs could prioritize research into indigenous practices, formalizing concepts like jugaad, dharma-based leadership, or adaptive strategy in chaotic markets.
- Global Advocacy: Indian business leaders and academics need to publish and promote their ideas in global forums, branding them as universally applicable.
- Bridge Academia and Industry: Stronger collaboration between Indian corporations and academia could help translate practical successes into theoretical frameworks.
- Cultural Confidence: Embracing and systematizing India’s unique approaches, rather than defaulting to Western models, could foster the development of home grown theories.
Indian managers have excelled globally because they are highly adaptable, hardworking, and capable of handling complex, resource-constrained environments. These qualities make them effective leaders on the international stage.
So, it’s not about the lack of talent — it’s more about the system not yet prioritizing theory-building or global promotion of Indian-origin models.
In short, the problem stems from a mix of cultural, institutional, and systemic factors that prioritize practical success over theoretical innovation. With deliberate effort to document and globalize Indian management practices, this gap could be bridged.
India has a rich history of philosophical and spiritual traditions that have influenced thought leadership in various fields. However, modern management concepts and theories have largely originated in the Western world.
Emerging Trends:
- Growing Interest in Indian Management Thought: There’s a growing interest in exploring Indian management philosophies, such as Gandhian management and Ayurvedic management.
- Indigenous Management Research: Indian researchers are increasingly focusing on developing context-specific management theories and practices.
While India may not have created many modern management concepts and theories, there is a growing recognition of the value of indigenous knowledge and practices. This shift could lead to the development of unique management approaches that blend Western theories with Indian cultural and philosophical traditions.
Stay connected with us on social media platforms for instant updates click here to join our LinkedIn, Twitter & Facebook
