Article (August-2018)


Paradigm shift of industrial relations in India

Dr. Anupriyo Mallick

Designation : -   Faculty and Head-HR and OB

Organization : -  Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning in Management (EIILM), Kolkata


7253 Total View        

The divide between brick and click industries is no longer the topic of an intense debate like it was a decade ago. In late 1990s and early 2000s, this was a great debate among the HR professionals from service/IT/knowledge industry on one hand and manufacturing HR professionals on the other. A new generation of HR leaders who had cut their teeth in the new age industries post liberalization had come to successfully occupy HR leadership roles and the rough and tumble of factory life was replaced by the paperless gleam of HR offices in IT parks. Years of strife, free economic growth continued and it seemed that Industrial Relations as a respected specialised discipline within HR was a thing of the past. IR was merely seen as adherence to labour laws and helping organisations stay compliant. While the practicing IR professionals and seasoned HR leaders never came around to accepting this, the focus within the large sections of HR fraternity clearly moved to managing the 'war for talent'.
Many large, multinational conglomerates were wiser as young professionals were still groomed by moving from a factory to a corporate role and thus developed into well - rounded HR professionals who drove a broader, more comprehensive agenda. But more often than not, the board room presentation by HR leaders was about talent management than industrial relations. Nothing wrong with that per se but the recent upsurge of industrial action in manufacturing industries is a reminder that the composition of employees in a manufacturing industry is diverse, requires sensitivity in approach, skillful handling and equal, pre-emptive focus on IR which if not done can simply destroy shareholder value.
In India Employer - Employee relation started with Industrialisation, at initial stages all employees were on permanent rolls of the company/organization (Few initial years as temporary and thereafter permanent employee/workers). But now the main focus in India is shifted from Employer - Employee relation to Employer - contractor (Contract Labour) relation to avoid the union related issues. Most of the companies are now outsourcing the manpower to 3rd party agency so that they can avoid union issues and complications. One thing is notable that the rate (Number) of dispute filing in Industrial court, Labour Court, Labour Office is drastically reduced since 80-90s as compare to 2016-17. It doesn't means that labours are not exploited in current scenario, where labour class is not interested as they work in contract and contractor is the supremo for them. They cannot catch - hold of Principle employer as there is no legal relationship set. Point to be noted here that most of the work is getting outsourced where contractor (labour supplier) class is getting benefit where employer is more comfortable as they can avoid unions.
Industrial relations tensions in India had never really gone away from the work place but various factors have contributed to the increased trend of labour unrest in last couple of years. In the last 20 years, after the opening up of the Indian economy, militant labour unrest had been on wane as political and legal support for it dwindled. Some years ago the acceptance of the need for contingent workers unwittingly paved the way for large number of contract employees being brought on board. These two factors coupled together became easy temptation for the management to push hard on discipline and productivity but the wages and dignity of workers did not rise in same proportion.